Near the end of each baseball season, a player is nominated and voted on as Favorite New Oriole by life and regular members of the Advocates. The following are players selected by the Oriole Advocates since 1966.
| Favorite New Oriole |
| Year |
Oriole |
Year |
Oriole |
| 1966 |
Frank Robinson |
1967 |
Tom Phoebus |
| 1968 |
Don Buford |
1969 |
Mike Cuellar |
| 1971 |
Pat Dobson |
1972 |
Bobby Grich |
| 1973 |
Al Bumbry
Rich Coggins |
1974 |
Ross Grimsley |
| 1975 |
Ken Singleton |
1976 |
Reggie Jackson |
| 1977 |
Eddie Murray |
1978 |
Don Stanhouse |
| 1979 |
Gary Roenicke |
1980 |
Dan Graham |
| 1981 |
Jose Morales |
1982 |
Cal Ripken, Jr. |
| 1983 |
Mike Boddicker |
1984 |
Floyd Rayford |
| 1985 |
Lee Lacy |
1986 |
Jim Traber |
| 1987 |
Terry Kennedy |
1988 |
Mickey Tettleton
Phil Bradley |
| 1989 |
Gregg Olsen |
1990 |
Ben McDonald |
| 1991 |
Dwight Evans |
1992 |
Alan Mills
Rick Sutcliffe |
| 1993 |
Jamie Moyer |
1994 |
Raphael Palmiero |
| 1995 |
Bobby Bonilla |
1996 |
Roberto Alomar |
| 1997 |
Jimmy Key |
1998 |
Sidney Ponson |
| 1999 |
Jeff Conine |
2000 |
Jose Mercedes |
| 2001 |
Josh Towers |
2002 |
Rodrigo Lopez |
| 2003 |
Deivi Cruz |
2004 |
Miguel Tejada |
| 2005 |
Sal Fassano |
2006 |
Nick Markakis |
| 2007 |
Jeremy Guthrie |
2008 |
Adam Jones |
| 2009 |
Nolan Reimold |
|
|
|
|